[Solution] Trying to convert Float8_e4m3fn to the MPS backend but it does not have support for that dtype

If you’re running ComfyUI on an Apple Silicon Mac (M1/M2), you might have encountered the frustrating error message: “Trying to convert Float8_e4m3fn to the MPS backend but it does not have support for that dtype“. This comprehensive guide will walk you through understanding and solving this error, ensuring smooth operation of your AI workflows on Apple Silicon.

Understanding the Error

What’s Actually Happening?

The error occurs due to a compatibility issue between three key components:

1. The Float8_e4m3fn data type (an 8-bit floating-point format)
2. Apple’s Metal Performance Shaders (MPS) backend
3. Your M1/M2 Mac’s neural engine architecture

This mismatch happens because while Apple Silicon chips are incredibly powerful, they have specific requirements for data types and computational processes, especially when dealing with machine learning models.

Technical Deep Dive

The Float8_e4m3fn Format

The “Float8_e4m3fn” might look like a cryptic string, but let’s break it down:

• Float8: 8-bit floating-point number
• e4: 4 bits for the exponent
• m3: 3 bits for the mantissa
• fn: indicates finite numbers only

This format is designed for efficient AI computation, offering:

• Reduced memory usage
• Faster processing speeds
• Lower power consumption

However, not all hardware and software combinations fully support this format, leading to our current predicament.

Solution for Trying to convert Float8_e4m3fn to the MPS backend but it does not have support for that dtype

Quick Fix Command

The most straightforward solution is to use the following command when running your ComfyUI installation:

python main.py --force-fp16 --use-split-cross-attention --cpu

Let’s break down what each flag does:

1. --force-fp16:
   • Forces the model to use 16-bit floating-point precision
   • More widely supported than Float8_e4m3fn
   • Provides a good balance between accuracy and performance
2. --use-split-cross-attention:
   • Optimizes memory usage during attention computations
   • Helps prevent out-of-memory errors
   • Particularly useful for large models
3. --cpu:
   • Falls back to CPU processing if MPS issues persist
   • Serves as a reliability failsafe
   • Note: This may impact performance but ensures functionality

Comprehensive Solution Approach

1. Environment Setup

First, ensure your PyTorch installation is up to date:

# Check current PyTorch version
python -c "import torch; print(torch.__version__)"

# Update PyTorch
pip install --upgrade torch torchvision torchaudio

2. Model Configuration

If you’re writing custom code, you can explicitly set the data type:

#Python Code

import torch

# Option 1: Convert model to float16
model = model.to(torch.float16)

# Option 2: Use CPU if needed
model = model.to(torch.device('cpu'))

3. ComfyUI Interface Settings

In the ComfyUI graphical interface:

1. Navigate to Model Loading Settings
2. Look for “Weight Data Type” or similar options
3. Select one of:
   • float16 (recommended)
   • float32 (if you need higher precision)
   • default (system-determined)

Performance Optimization Tips

1. Memory Management

When working with AI models on M1/M2 Macs:

• Monitor memory usage using Activity Monitor
• Close unnecessary applications
• Consider using smaller batch sizes
• Enable memory-efficient attention mechanisms

2. Speed Optimization

To maintain optimal performance:

• Use float16 precision when possible
• Enable MPS acceleration when stable
• Implement batching for multiple operations
• Consider model pruning or quantization

3. Stability Measures

For increased stability:

• Keep software updated
• Monitor system temperature
• Use appropriate cooling solutions
• Implement error handling in your workflows

Common Pitfalls and Solutions

1. Version Mismatches

Problem: Incompatible PyTorch versions Solution:

pip uninstall torch torchvision torchaudio

 pip install --upgrade torch torchvision torchaudio

2. Memory Issues

Problem: Out of memory errors Solution:

• Reduce batch size
• Enable memory-efficient attention
• Use the --use-split-cross-attention flag

3. Performance Degradation

Problem: Slow processing after fixes Solution:

• Monitor CPU/GPU usage
• Adjust precision settings
• Consider model optimization

Best Practices for M1/M2 Mac Users

1. Regular Maintenance

• Keep your system updated
• Monitor temperature and performance
• Clean up unused models and caches
• Regularly check for ComfyUI updates

2. Workflow Optimization

• Start with smaller models
• Test changes incrementally
• Document successful configurations
• Create backup workflows

3. Community Resources

• Join ComfyUI Discord or forums
• Share successful configurations
• Report bugs and solutions
• Contribute to documentation

Troubleshooting Checklist

Before running your workflow:

✓ Updated PyTorch installation

✓ Correct command-line arguments

✓ Appropriate model settings

✓ Sufficient system resources

✓ Backup workflow ready

✓ Error logging enabled

Future Considerations

As Apple Silicon and PyTorch continue to evolve:

• Watch for MPS backend improvements
• Monitor Float8_e4m3fn support updates
• Stay informed about new optimization techniques
• Consider contributing to open-source solutions

Conclusion

While the Float8_e4m3fn to MPS backend error can be frustrating, it’s solvable with the right approach. By using the provided command-line arguments and following the optimization guidelines, you can successfully run ComfyUI on your M1/M2 Mac. Remember to stay updated with the latest developments and contribute your experiences to the community.

Additional Resources

• Official PyTorch Documentation
• Apple Developer – Metal
• ComfyUI GitHub Repository
• M1/M2 Mac Optimization Guides

About the Author

This guide was created to help the AI community better understand and resolve common issues when working with ComfyUI on Apple Silicon machines. If you found this helpful, please share it with others who might benefit from this information.

---

Last updated: November 2024 For more technical guides and solutions, visit Study Warehouse